Labour lost


Johann Lamont stood down as leader of the Scottish Labour party. She accused colleagues of trying to run Scotland “like a branch office of London and describing some of her Westminster colleagues as dinosaurs who do not understand the politics of Scotland in the new post-referendum world.

What brought about her resignation was the sacking of the general secretary of Scottish Labour, Ian Price without the London HQ of the party even bothering to consult her.

The truth of the matter is that neither the Scottish nor Welsh Labour parties are anything but branch offices of the centralist party.

Although Carwyn Jones was elected leader of the Welsh Labour party, all the paid officers in the Welsh party HQ are there courtesy of the national executive of the central party.

Just like in Scotland the national party general secretary could invite them to London for a “chat” and promptly give them the boot.

Whilst Wales’s First Minister calls for Home rule his party is very much into central control.

Party candidates have to be approved by the National executive. They can impose their will on local constituencies and also the Welsh party.

The Welsh party may have its own logo and call itself Welsh Labour but make no mistake it’s independent in name only.  Welsh Labour was a branding exercise to allow Rhodri Morgan to claim clear red water between Wales and Blair’s New Labour.

The problem with Labour is that it has never really understood devolution. Its focus first and foremost is Westminster.  Their only concern is that Wales and Scotland provide the cannon fodder of Labour MPs in such quantity to allow a Labour government be formed.

If they had any understanding of Scotland, would they have been seen campaigning alongside and sharing the same platform as the Conservatives in the Better Together campaign? Unlikely, traditional Labour voters saw this as a betrayal.

Although Scotland rejected independence it’s not the SNP that are the losers in eyes of the voters. In the greater Glasgow area, 12 Labour constituencies backed independence. Since the referendum, SNP membership has more than tripled with the party becoming the third largest in the UK.

Meanwhile Labour is in free fall. Sacking their general secretary, losing their leader. Hardly the best background to return Labour MPs.

Henry McLeish, a former Labour first minister, said that Scottish Labour supporters no longer know “what the party stands for.”  They are unlikely to ever “know” until Labour in Scotland and in Wales become independent of the metropolitan clique that control the party.


This entry was posted by Gareth Hughes on at and is filed under Blog Post. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

6 Responses to “Labour lost”

  1. Glyn Erasmus says:


  2. The Earthshaker says:

    Good analysis you should be commended for your honesty.

    Just a shame it’s taken a Scottish independence referendum and a big fall in Labour support in Scotland for a respected welsh journalist and not one linked to the mainstream media to tell it like it is and expose the fraud that is Welsh Labour.

    The Scots may not have voted for independence, but at least a good proportion of the electorate has seen through Labour’s self serving agenda, sadly that will never happen in Wales as we slide into irrelevance voting Labour till we die.

  3. John Owen says:

    You can’t make the same comparison between Scotland and Wales. They are two different countries, indeed if you can call Wales a country. I was a student in Scotland and worked there for several years. It has a national identity far bigger than Wales it has a large SCOTTISH middle class and intelligentsia, which identifies with Scotland. It had SCOTTISH Universities, not second rate English Universities that replaced the University of Wales nandcits people are more polically mature. If and it’s a big if, Labour implodes in Wales, it will be replaced by UKIP.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>